Harper On Buying A Home
Harpernomics Says
“Our plan is simple, modest and practical. It is a tax credit for buyers and for the construction industry. This will make home ownership more affordable and it will create jobs.”
Stephen Harper, Canadian Press, September 16, 2008
The Reality Is...
A $750 tax break on a three hundred thousand dollar home will do little to make home ownership “more affordable” and nothing to “create jobs.”
"I suspect it might have a marginal impact. I would say that that would have a modest effect. It's unlikely to bring in thousands of people.”
Doug Porter, Bank of Montreal deputy chief economist, Toronto Sun, September 17, 2008
“Prime Minister Stephen Harper says in a period of economic uncertainty "it’s not the time for wild experiments, new taxes or grand new spending schemes." Yet he proposed two big outlays this week – $150 million to allow the self-employed to opt into EI maternity benefits and $200 million to give first-time home buyers a $750 tax break. These target certain voter demographics but don’t compare in importance to supplying enough doctors or covering life-saving drugs.
The EI change will raise premiums (i.e. taxes) for employees, who don’t have the choice of volunteering for coverage. And $750 – less than the cost of one oral chemo prescription – is not going to make or break a house purchase.
Good economic management is using the public funds available on what really matters and on the gravest needs. Mr. Harper’s two goodies fail that test.”
Editorial, Halifax Chronicle Herald, September 17, 2008